Job Description – Review Guidance
# NHS Job Descriptions and Pay Band Reviews
## A Guide to Reviewing Your Job Description and Understanding the NHS Job Evaluation Process
**Has your NHS role changed? Are you carrying out additional responsibilities that are not reflected in your job description? Do you believe your current Agenda for Change pay band no longer reflects the work you are required to undertake?**
If so, it may be time to request a review of your job description.
GMB Plymouth Health Branch is here to help members understand the NHS Job Evaluation Scheme, their rights and the steps involved in requesting a job description review or reassessment of their pay band.
This guide explains how the process works, what evidence you may need and where to get support.
**Official guidance:** [NHS Job Evaluation Handbook – NHS Employers](https://www.nhsemployers.org/publications/nhs-job-evaluation-handbook)
—
## What Is the NHS Job Evaluation Scheme?
The NHS Job Evaluation Scheme is used to determine the appropriate pay band for posts covered by Agenda for Change (AfC).
The scheme evaluates the requirements of a job, including the knowledge, skills, responsibilities and effort needed to carry out the role.
Its purpose is to support fair, consistent and equitable pay arrangements across the NHS.
**The important thing to remember is that job evaluation assesses the requirements of the post, not the individual employee, their personal performance or how hard they work.**
### Job Description Review vs Pay Band Review
Although closely connected, these are not the same process.
**Job Description Review**
A review checks whether your existing job description accurately reflects the duties and responsibilities you are currently required to undertake.
An updated job description does not automatically result in a higher pay band.
**Job Evaluation or Re-matching**
This is the formal process used to assess a post against the NHS Job Evaluation Scheme and determine the appropriate Agenda for Change pay band.
**Changed-Job Review**
Where an existing post has changed significantly, it may be appropriate to request reassessment through the applicable changed-job procedure.
**Review of a Job Evaluation Outcome**
If you disagree with a formal job matching or evaluation outcome, you may be able to request a review of that decision through the prescribed procedure.
These processes are related but have different purposes and requirements.
—
## When Should You Request a Job Description Review?
Your job description should accurately reflect the substantive duties and responsibilities of your role.
A review may be appropriate where there have been significant or sustained changes, such as:
– Taking on additional responsibilities that were not previously part of your role.
– Increased responsibility for supervising, training or managing other staff.
– Greater autonomy or independent decision-making.
– Additional responsibility for budgets, resources, equipment or services.
– Changes in clinical, technical or specialist responsibilities.
– Increased responsibility for governance, risk management or patient safety.
– Significant changes in communication demands or the complexity of the work.
– Changes arising from service redesign, restructuring or new working arrangements.
– Increased physical, mental or emotional effort required by the post.
**Not every change in duties will justify a higher pay band.** The key question is whether the requirements of the job have changed sufficiently to warrant reassessment under the NHS Job Evaluation Scheme.
Temporary cover, increased workload or staff shortages do not automatically justify re-banding, although they may raise other workplace concerns that should be addressed.
—
## How Does the Job Description Review Process Work?
The process may vary slightly between NHS organisations, depending on local policies and partnership agreements.
However, the following steps provide a general guide.
### Step 1 – Identify What Has Changed
Start by reviewing your existing job description.
Consider:
– Which duties are no longer accurate?
– What additional responsibilities are you now expected to undertake?
– When did these changes begin?
– Are the changes permanent, ongoing or temporary?
– Has your level of responsibility or decision-making increased?
– Have the changes been formally agreed or introduced through changes in working practices?
Make a written record of the differences between your original role and your current responsibilities.
### Step 2 – Discuss Your Concerns with Your Line Manager
Arrange a meeting with your line manager to discuss whether your job description accurately reflects your current role.
Explain the changes you have identified and provide examples where possible.
Ask whether your manager agrees that the job description needs updating and whether the changes may warrant consideration under the Job Evaluation Scheme.
**GMB members can seek advice from their Workplace Representative before or during this process.**
### Step 3 – Update Your Job Description
Where changes are identified, your job description should be updated using the relevant organisational template and local procedures.
An accurate job description should explain:
– The overall purpose of the role.
– Main duties and responsibilities.
– Reporting and accountability arrangements.
– Decision-making responsibilities.
– Supervisory or management responsibilities.
– Communication and working relationships.
– Relevant working conditions and demands.
The description should reflect the actual requirements of the post rather than being written to achieve a particular pay band.
Where possible, the updated job description should be agreed between the jobholder and their manager.
### Step 4 – Submit the Job for Consideration
If the changes are sufficiently significant, the updated job description may be submitted to the appropriate HR, Workforce or Job Evaluation Team.
Depending on the circumstances and local procedures, the post may be considered through:
– Job matching against an appropriate national job profile.
– Reassessment under the changed-job procedure.
– Local job evaluation where no suitable national profile exists.
The correct route should be determined in accordance with the NHS Job Evaluation Handbook and local partnership arrangements.
### Step 5 – Job Matching or Evaluation Panel
Where formal matching or evaluation is required, trained practitioners assess the job using the NHS Job Evaluation Scheme.
The process operates through partnership arrangements involving management and staff-side representatives.
The panel considers the requirements of the post and the supporting evidence.
It may request additional information or clarification before reaching an outcome.
### Step 6 – Receive the Outcome
The outcome may confirm that:
– Your existing pay band remains appropriate.
– Your post should be allocated to a different pay band.
– Further information or clarification is required.
– Additional work is needed before an outcome can be determined.
A reassessment can potentially result in a higher band, the same band or a lower band.
Where a banding change is agreed, the effective date of any pay adjustment and any applicable pay protection must be considered under the relevant national and local arrangements.
**A successful re-banding does not automatically mean that additional pay will be backdated to the date you first raised your concerns.**
### Step 7 – What If You Disagree with the Outcome?
If you disagree with a formal job matching or evaluation decision, you may be able to request an outcome review.
The NHS Job Evaluation Handbook sets out the applicable review arrangements, including requirements for submitting reasons and supporting evidence.
**Review requests are subject to procedural deadlines, so do not delay seeking advice.**
A review of an evaluation outcome is different from requesting a fresh assessment because the duties of a post have subsequently changed.
Contact your GMB Workplace Representative for guidance on the appropriate process.
—
## What Evidence Should You Collect?
Providing clear, factual evidence can help demonstrate how your role has changed.
Useful documents may include:
– Your original job description and person specification.
– Your current or proposed updated job description.
– A written comparison of previous and current responsibilities.
– Organisation charts showing reporting arrangements.
– Evidence of additional supervisory or management responsibilities.
– Examples of increased autonomy or decision-making.
– Details of new clinical, technical or specialist duties.
– Relevant correspondence confirming changes to your role.
– Dates showing when additional responsibilities began.
– Any locally required job evaluation questionnaires or supporting forms.
### Keep Your Evidence Relevant
Focus on the responsibilities and requirements of the post.
For example, rather than simply stating that you are doing more work, explain whether you are now required to make decisions independently, manage additional risks or undertake responsibilities that were not previously part of the role.
Avoid including identifiable patient information or confidential employment records unless there is a lawful and appropriate reason to provide them.
—
## What If Your Manager Does Not Agree That Your Job Has Changed?
Sometimes employees and managers disagree about whether a job description accurately reflects the role.
If this happens:
1. Ask your manager to explain which responsibilities they believe are already covered by your existing job description.
2. Provide clear examples of the duties you believe have changed.
3. Request written clarification of any disputed responsibilities.
4. Keep records of relevant discussions and correspondence.
5. Contact your GMB Workplace Representative for advice.
6. Ask HR or the Job Evaluation Team about the appropriate local procedure for resolving disagreements.
A manager’s disagreement does not automatically mean that your concerns are unjustified.
However, the appropriate local procedure must be followed to determine whether the post has changed sufficiently to warrant formal reassessment.
—
## Frequently Asked Questions
### Can I Request Re-banding Because My Workload Has Increased?
An increased workload does not automatically justify a higher pay band.
The Job Evaluation Scheme assesses the requirements of the post rather than the volume of work, individual performance or staffing pressures.
However, if your increased workload involves significant changes to your responsibilities, autonomy, knowledge requirements or other job evaluation factors, a review may be appropriate.
### What If I Have Been Carrying Out Higher-Level Duties for Several Years?
You should raise this with your manager and seek GMB advice.
The length of time you have undertaken additional duties may be relevant evidence, but it does not automatically establish entitlement to a higher pay band or retrospective payment.
### Can My Pay Band Go Down Following a Review?
Yes. A formal job evaluation assessment can result in a higher, unchanged or lower pay band, depending on the requirements of the post.
Any applicable pay protection or contractual implications would need to be considered separately.
### Does My Manager Have to Agree to a Job Description Review?
Your manager will normally be involved in confirming the duties and responsibilities of your post.
If you cannot agree on the accuracy of your job description, you should seek advice about the relevant local dispute-resolution or job evaluation procedure.
### Should I Rewrite My Job Description Using the Job Evaluation Factors?
No.
Your job description should accurately explain what the job requires in ordinary workplace language.
It should not be artificially written around the Job Evaluation Scheme’s factor terminology or national job profiles.
### Can GMB Help Me with a Job Description or Banding Review?
Yes.
Your GMB Workplace Representative can provide guidance, help you understand the process, discuss the evidence you may need and support you in raising concerns through the appropriate workplace procedures.
—
## How GMB Plymouth Health Branch Can Help
GMB believes that NHS staff should be fairly recognised and rewarded for the responsibilities they undertake.
If you believe your job description no longer accurately reflects your role, we encourage you to seek advice before submitting a formal review request.
GMB representatives can help members:
– Understand the Agenda for Change Job Evaluation process.
– Identify relevant changes in duties and responsibilities.
– Prepare for discussions with management.
– Understand the evidence required for a review.
– Navigate local procedures and formal review arrangements.
– Raise concerns about fairness and consistency.
**You do not have to navigate the process without support.**
### Contact GMB Plymouth Health Branch
For advice about your job description, Agenda for Change pay band or a potential job evaluation review, contact your local GMB Workplace Representative.
You can also contact the Plymouth Health Branch:
**Email:** [enquiry@gmb-plymouth-health.com](mailto:enquiry@gmb-plymouth-health.com)
**Please include:** Your name, workplace, current pay band and a brief explanation of your concerns.
—
## Useful Resources
[**NHS Job Evaluation Handbook – NHS Employers**](https://www.nhsemployers.org/publications/nhs-job-evaluation-handbook)
The official national guidance covering job matching, local evaluation, changed jobs and review arrangements under the NHS Job Evaluation Scheme.
[**NHS Terms and Conditions of Service Handbook**](https://www.nhsemployers.org/publications/tchandbook)
Information about the national Agenda for Change terms and conditions framework.
—
## Think Your Role Has Changed? Speak to GMB.
If your duties and responsibilities have significantly changed but your pay band has remained the same, speak to your GMB Workplace Representative.
Getting advice early can help you understand your options, gather appropriate evidence and follow the correct procedure.
**GMB UNION – STRONGER TOGETHER**
*Disclaimer: This guide provides general information for NHS employees covered by Agenda for Change. It does not replace the NHS Job Evaluation Handbook, local partnership agreements or individual employment advice. Procedures and entitlements may vary depending on the circumstances.*
This version is suitable for a full website information page, with clear headings for mobile readers, a practical seven-step process, FAQs and a contact section.
